Gobernanza y Calidad en la Educación Superior: Una Descripción Bibliométrica
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.21664/2238-8869.2021v10i3.p252-265Keywords:
governance, quality, higher education, trends, emerging themesAbstract
Considering that contemporary universities face significant pressure to restructure their management practices, this article aims to identify trends in scientific production in relation to governance and quality in the field of higher education. For this end, a bibliometric analysis of the articles of journals indexed to Web of Science published between 2010 and 2020 was carried out. Bibliometrix and VOSviewer were used for data analysis and visualization of bibliometric maps. The results show a strong increase in scientific production if the extreme years of the period analyzed are compared. Likewise, three main research topics were identified, namely, 1) laws and reforms to higher education, 2) perceptions of academics about the reforms, the new teaching scenario and their levels of satisfaction, and 3) commitment and participation of the student. We conclude that, from a transversal perspective, the leadership of the directors, the participation and critical thinking of the students and the collaboration between higher education institutions are fundamental topics for the institutions to fulfill their roles with an emphasis on quality.
Finally, a field is projected with growing publications that address this issue if one considers the current framework of world higher education where the ideals of deregulation, quality and financial autonomy are considering as urgent needs.
References
Acosta-Silva A, Ganga-Contreras F, Rama-Vitale C 2021. Gobernanza universitaria: Enfoques y alcances conceptuales. Revista Iberoamericana de Educación Superior 12(33): 3-17.
Almarghani EM, Mijatovic I 2017. Factors affecting student engagement in HEIs - it is all about good teaching. Teaching in Higher Education 22(8): 940-956.
Aria M, Cuccurullo C 2017. Bibliometrix: An R-Tool for comprehensive science mapping analysis. Journal of Informetrics 11(4): 959-975.
Asiyai RI 2020. Best practices for quality assurance in higher education: implications for educational administration. International Journal of Leadership in Education: 1-12.
Brooks R, Byford K, Sela K 2015. The changing role of students’ unions within contemporary higher education. Journal of Education Policy 30(2): 165-181.
Brunner JJ, Labraña J, Ganga F, Rodríguez-Ponce E 2020. Gobernanza de la educación superior: El papel de las ideas en las políticas. Revista Iberoamericana de Educación 83(1): 211-238.
Carey P 2013. Student as co-producer in a marketised higher education system: A case study of students’ experience of participation in curriculum design. Innovations in Education and Teaching International 50(3): 250-260.
Cho YH, Palmer JD 2013. Stakeholders’ views of South Korea’s higher education internationalization policy. Higher Education 65(3): 291-308.
Danvila del Valle I, Estévez-Mendoza C, Lara FJ 2019. Human resources training: A bibliometric analysis. Journal of Business Research 101: 627-636.
De Silva Lokuwaduge C, Armstrong A 2015. The impact of governance on the performance of the higher education sector in Australia. Educational Management Administration & Leadership 43(5): 811-827.
Desai N, Veras L, Gosain A 2018. Using Bradford’s law of scattering to identify the core journals of pediatric surgery. Journal of Surgical Research 229: 90-95.
Dicker R, Garcia M, Kelly A, Mulrooney H 2019. What does “quality” in higher education mean? Perceptions of staff, students and employers. Studies in Higher Education, 44(8): 1425-1441.
Dougherty KJ, Natow RS 2020. Performance-based funding for higher education: How well does neoliberal theory capture neoliberal practice?. Higher Education 80: 457-478.
Dwaikat NY 2021. A comprehensive model for assessing the quality in higher education institutions. The TQM Journal 33(4): 841-855.
Gerged A, Elheddad M 2020. How can national governance affect education quality in Western Europe?. International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education 21(3): 413-426.
Gryaznova A 2018. Supervisory boards in Russian universities: A development instrument or another tool of state control?. Higher Education 76(1): 35-50.
Guerrero Sánchez P, Ibarra Uribe LM, Mercado Yebra J 2016. Los indicadores de calidad y su relación con la ética en la producción académica. Estudio de casos comparados. RIDE. Revista Iberoamericana para la Investigación y el Desarrollo Educativo 7(13): 197-219.
Hartley M, Gopaul B, Sagintayeva A, Apergenova R 2016. Learning autonomy: Higher education reform in Kazakhstan. Higher Education 72(3): 277-289.
Jalal SK (2019). Co-authorship and co-occurrences analysis using Bibliometrix R-Package: A case study of India and Bangladesh. Annals of Library and Information Studies (ALIS) 66(2): 57-64.
Jauhiainen A, Jauhiainen A, Laiho A, Lehto R 2015. Fabrications, time-consuming bureaucracy and moral dilemmas — Finnish university employees’ experiences on the governance of university work. Higher Education Policy 28(3): 393-410.
Jedemark M, Londos M 2021. Four different assessment practices: How university teachers handle the field of tension between professional responsibility and professional accountability. Higher Education 81: 1293-1309.
Kaufmann D, Kraay A, Mastruzzi M 2011. The worldwide governance indicators: Methodology and analytical issues. Hague Journal on the Rule of Law 3(2): 220-246.
Krüger K, Parellada M, Samoilovich D, Sursock A 2019. Implementando las reformas de la gobernanza: Las reglas de juego en los sistemas universitarios europeos. Revista de Educación 385: 11-37.
Li X, Zhao G 2020. Democratic involvement in higher education: A study of Chinese student e-participation in university governance. Higher Education Policy 33: 65-87.
López-Robles JR, Otegi-Olaso JR, Gómez IP, Cobo MJ 2019. 30 years of intelligence models in management and business: A bibliometric review. International Journal of Information Management 48: 22-38.
McCowan T 2018. Quality of higher education in Kenya: Addressing the conundrum. International Journal of Educational Development 60: 128-137.
Mendes AB, Hammett D 2020. The new tyranny of student participation? Student voice and the paradox of strategic-active student-citizens. Teaching in Higher Education: 1-16.
Merigó JM, Yang JB 2017. A bibliometric analysis of operations research and management science. Omega 73: 37-48.
Mongeon P, Paul-Hus A 2016. The journal coverage of Web of Science and Scopus: A comparative analysis. Scientometrics 106(1): 213-228.
Naylor R, Dollinger M, Mahat M, Khawaja M 2021. Students as customers versus as active agents: Conceptualising the student role in governance and quality assurance. Higher Education Research & Development 40(5): 1026-1039.
Nguyen HT, Hamid MO, Moni K 2016. English-medium instruction and self-governance in higher education: the journey of a Vietnamese university through the institutional autonomy regime. Higher Education 72(5): 669-683.
Olaskoaga-Larrauri J, González-Laskibar X, Barrenetxea-Ayesta M, Díaz-De-Basurto-Uraga P 2019a. The sign of the new millennium. Organisational changes and job satisfaction at Spanish public universities. European Journal of Education 54(1): 137-150.
Olaskoaga-Larrauri J, González-Laskibar X, Díaz-De-Basurto-Uraga P 2019b. Spanish university reforms and job satisfaction. Educational Policy 33(2): 1-28.
Olaskoaga-Larrauri J, Rodríguez-Armenta CE, Marúm-Espinosa E 2020. The direction of reforms and job satisfaction among teaching staff in higher education in Mexico. Teaching in Higher Education: 1-17.
Ong K, Chan D 2012. Transnational higher education and challenges for university governance in China. Higher Education Policy 25: 151-170.
Peregrina MI, Álvarez EL 2021. Eco-innovación, concepto clave para de desarrollo sostenible: Una revisión bibliométrica 2000-2020. Fronteiras: Journal of Social, Technological and Environmental Science 10(1): 36-60.
Prakash G 2018. Quality in higher education institutions: Insights from the literature. The TQM Journal 30(6), 732-748.
Raamkumar AS, Foo S, Pang N 2017. Using author-specified keywords in building an initial reading list of research papers in scientific paper retrieval and recommender systems. Information Processing & Management 53(3): 577-594.
Riad Shams S, Belyaeva Z 2019. Quality assurance driving factors as antecedents of knowledge management: A stakeholder-focussed perspective in higher education. Journal of the Knowledge Economy 10(2): 423-436.
Song SY 2020. How does variation in the State’s choice over higher education governance affect university restructuring? A time-series-cross-sectional analysis. Education and Urban Society 52(1): 92-116.
St George E 2020. Higher education quality and autonomy—a case study of Lao PDR. Higher Education 79: 753-771.
Steinhardt I, Schneijderberg C, Götze N, Baumann J, Krücken G 2017. Mapping the quality assurance of teaching and learning in higher education: The emergence of a specialty?. Higher Education 74(2): 221-237.
Stromquist NP 2017. The professoriate: The challenged subject in US higher education. Comparative Education 53(1): 132-146.
Teelken C 2012. Compliance or pragmatism: How do academics deal with managerialism in higher education? A comparative study in three countries. Studies in Higher Education 37(3): 271-290.
Tepayakul R, Rinthaisong I 2018. Job satisfaction and employee engagement among human resources staff of Thai private higher education institutions. The Journal of Behavioral Science 13(2): 68-81.
Tham SY, Mahmod NKN, Alavi R 2013. Assessing policies for attracting international students: Case of Malaysia. Asia Pacific Journal of Education 33(1): 112-126.
van Eck NJ, Waltman L 2010. Software survey: Vosviewer, a computer program for bibliometric mapping. Scientometrics 84(2): 523-538.
Zhang J, Yu Q, Zheng F, Long C, Lu Z, Duan Z 2016. Comparing keywords plus of WOS and author keywords: A case study of patient adherence research. Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology 67(4): 967-972.
Almarghani EM, Mijatovic I 2017. Factors affecting student engagement in HEIs - it is all about good teaching. Teaching in Higher Education 22(8): 940-956.
Aria M, Cuccurullo C 2017. Bibliometrix: An R-Tool for comprehensive science mapping analysis. Journal of Informetrics 11(4): 959-975.
Asiyai RI 2020. Best practices for quality assurance in higher education: implications for educational administration. International Journal of Leadership in Education: 1-12.
Brooks R, Byford K, Sela K 2015. The changing role of students’ unions within contemporary higher education. Journal of Education Policy 30(2): 165-181.
Brunner JJ, Labraña J, Ganga F, Rodríguez-Ponce E 2020. Gobernanza de la educación superior: El papel de las ideas en las políticas. Revista Iberoamericana de Educación 83(1): 211-238.
Carey P 2013. Student as co-producer in a marketised higher education system: A case study of students’ experience of participation in curriculum design. Innovations in Education and Teaching International 50(3): 250-260.
Cho YH, Palmer JD 2013. Stakeholders’ views of South Korea’s higher education internationalization policy. Higher Education 65(3): 291-308.
Danvila del Valle I, Estévez-Mendoza C, Lara FJ 2019. Human resources training: A bibliometric analysis. Journal of Business Research 101: 627-636.
De Silva Lokuwaduge C, Armstrong A 2015. The impact of governance on the performance of the higher education sector in Australia. Educational Management Administration & Leadership 43(5): 811-827.
Desai N, Veras L, Gosain A 2018. Using Bradford’s law of scattering to identify the core journals of pediatric surgery. Journal of Surgical Research 229: 90-95.
Dicker R, Garcia M, Kelly A, Mulrooney H 2019. What does “quality” in higher education mean? Perceptions of staff, students and employers. Studies in Higher Education, 44(8): 1425-1441.
Dougherty KJ, Natow RS 2020. Performance-based funding for higher education: How well does neoliberal theory capture neoliberal practice?. Higher Education 80: 457-478.
Dwaikat NY 2021. A comprehensive model for assessing the quality in higher education institutions. The TQM Journal 33(4): 841-855.
Gerged A, Elheddad M 2020. How can national governance affect education quality in Western Europe?. International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education 21(3): 413-426.
Gryaznova A 2018. Supervisory boards in Russian universities: A development instrument or another tool of state control?. Higher Education 76(1): 35-50.
Guerrero Sánchez P, Ibarra Uribe LM, Mercado Yebra J 2016. Los indicadores de calidad y su relación con la ética en la producción académica. Estudio de casos comparados. RIDE. Revista Iberoamericana para la Investigación y el Desarrollo Educativo 7(13): 197-219.
Hartley M, Gopaul B, Sagintayeva A, Apergenova R 2016. Learning autonomy: Higher education reform in Kazakhstan. Higher Education 72(3): 277-289.
Jalal SK (2019). Co-authorship and co-occurrences analysis using Bibliometrix R-Package: A case study of India and Bangladesh. Annals of Library and Information Studies (ALIS) 66(2): 57-64.
Jauhiainen A, Jauhiainen A, Laiho A, Lehto R 2015. Fabrications, time-consuming bureaucracy and moral dilemmas — Finnish university employees’ experiences on the governance of university work. Higher Education Policy 28(3): 393-410.
Jedemark M, Londos M 2021. Four different assessment practices: How university teachers handle the field of tension between professional responsibility and professional accountability. Higher Education 81: 1293-1309.
Kaufmann D, Kraay A, Mastruzzi M 2011. The worldwide governance indicators: Methodology and analytical issues. Hague Journal on the Rule of Law 3(2): 220-246.
Krüger K, Parellada M, Samoilovich D, Sursock A 2019. Implementando las reformas de la gobernanza: Las reglas de juego en los sistemas universitarios europeos. Revista de Educación 385: 11-37.
Li X, Zhao G 2020. Democratic involvement in higher education: A study of Chinese student e-participation in university governance. Higher Education Policy 33: 65-87.
López-Robles JR, Otegi-Olaso JR, Gómez IP, Cobo MJ 2019. 30 years of intelligence models in management and business: A bibliometric review. International Journal of Information Management 48: 22-38.
McCowan T 2018. Quality of higher education in Kenya: Addressing the conundrum. International Journal of Educational Development 60: 128-137.
Mendes AB, Hammett D 2020. The new tyranny of student participation? Student voice and the paradox of strategic-active student-citizens. Teaching in Higher Education: 1-16.
Merigó JM, Yang JB 2017. A bibliometric analysis of operations research and management science. Omega 73: 37-48.
Mongeon P, Paul-Hus A 2016. The journal coverage of Web of Science and Scopus: A comparative analysis. Scientometrics 106(1): 213-228.
Naylor R, Dollinger M, Mahat M, Khawaja M 2021. Students as customers versus as active agents: Conceptualising the student role in governance and quality assurance. Higher Education Research & Development 40(5): 1026-1039.
Nguyen HT, Hamid MO, Moni K 2016. English-medium instruction and self-governance in higher education: the journey of a Vietnamese university through the institutional autonomy regime. Higher Education 72(5): 669-683.
Olaskoaga-Larrauri J, González-Laskibar X, Barrenetxea-Ayesta M, Díaz-De-Basurto-Uraga P 2019a. The sign of the new millennium. Organisational changes and job satisfaction at Spanish public universities. European Journal of Education 54(1): 137-150.
Olaskoaga-Larrauri J, González-Laskibar X, Díaz-De-Basurto-Uraga P 2019b. Spanish university reforms and job satisfaction. Educational Policy 33(2): 1-28.
Olaskoaga-Larrauri J, Rodríguez-Armenta CE, Marúm-Espinosa E 2020. The direction of reforms and job satisfaction among teaching staff in higher education in Mexico. Teaching in Higher Education: 1-17.
Ong K, Chan D 2012. Transnational higher education and challenges for university governance in China. Higher Education Policy 25: 151-170.
Peregrina MI, Álvarez EL 2021. Eco-innovación, concepto clave para de desarrollo sostenible: Una revisión bibliométrica 2000-2020. Fronteiras: Journal of Social, Technological and Environmental Science 10(1): 36-60.
Prakash G 2018. Quality in higher education institutions: Insights from the literature. The TQM Journal 30(6), 732-748.
Raamkumar AS, Foo S, Pang N 2017. Using author-specified keywords in building an initial reading list of research papers in scientific paper retrieval and recommender systems. Information Processing & Management 53(3): 577-594.
Riad Shams S, Belyaeva Z 2019. Quality assurance driving factors as antecedents of knowledge management: A stakeholder-focussed perspective in higher education. Journal of the Knowledge Economy 10(2): 423-436.
Song SY 2020. How does variation in the State’s choice over higher education governance affect university restructuring? A time-series-cross-sectional analysis. Education and Urban Society 52(1): 92-116.
St George E 2020. Higher education quality and autonomy—a case study of Lao PDR. Higher Education 79: 753-771.
Steinhardt I, Schneijderberg C, Götze N, Baumann J, Krücken G 2017. Mapping the quality assurance of teaching and learning in higher education: The emergence of a specialty?. Higher Education 74(2): 221-237.
Stromquist NP 2017. The professoriate: The challenged subject in US higher education. Comparative Education 53(1): 132-146.
Teelken C 2012. Compliance or pragmatism: How do academics deal with managerialism in higher education? A comparative study in three countries. Studies in Higher Education 37(3): 271-290.
Tepayakul R, Rinthaisong I 2018. Job satisfaction and employee engagement among human resources staff of Thai private higher education institutions. The Journal of Behavioral Science 13(2): 68-81.
Tham SY, Mahmod NKN, Alavi R 2013. Assessing policies for attracting international students: Case of Malaysia. Asia Pacific Journal of Education 33(1): 112-126.
van Eck NJ, Waltman L 2010. Software survey: Vosviewer, a computer program for bibliometric mapping. Scientometrics 84(2): 523-538.
Zhang J, Yu Q, Zheng F, Long C, Lu Z, Duan Z 2016. Comparing keywords plus of WOS and author keywords: A case study of patient adherence research. Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology 67(4): 967-972.
Downloads
Published
2021-12-28
How to Cite
PEDRAJA-REJAS, Liliana; RODRÍGUEZ-PONCE, Emilio; MUñOZ-FRITIS, Camila. Gobernanza y Calidad en la Educación Superior: Una Descripción Bibliométrica. Fronteiras - Journal of Social, Technological and Environmental Science, [S. l.], v. 10, n. 3, p. 252–265, 2021. DOI: 10.21664/2238-8869.2021v10i3.p252-265. Disponível em: https://periodicos.unievangelica.edu.br/index.php/fronteiras/article/view/5805. Acesso em: 16 may. 2024.
Issue
Section
Articles
License
This journal offers immediate free access to its content, following the principle that providing free scientific knowledge to the public, we provides greater global democratization of knowledge.
As of the publication in the journal the authors have copyright and publication rights of their articles without restrictions.
The Revista Fronteiras: Journal of Social, Technological and Environmental Science follows the legal precepts of the Creative Commons - Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International. 
